Animal sentience in the moral maze
Animals should be treated humanely, but is there an agenda to devalue humanity?
(Apologies to those who received an earlier version of this post)
On BBC Radio’s Moral Maze this week, my co-panellists and I discussed animal sentience. A bill on that topic currently working its way through parliament would provide the first formal recognition in law that animals can experience feelings, including pain, joy and fear.
If the law is passed, the government will establish an animal sentience committee to scrutinise policy. Many hope it would offer animals greater protection from ill-treatment. Some want the bill to go even further by including invertebrates, which, for example, could ban the practice of boiling crustaceans alive. Critics of the proposals believe current legislation is sufficient to protect animals against pain and neglect, and worry about the unintended consequences of the bill not least for farming, fishing and countryside sports.
Is it time to think of some animals as occupying the same moral universe as humans? Or is this part of a long-standing attempt to ascribe to animals characteristics that define human beings alone and distinguish them from the animal kingdom, all in order to knock humanity off its pre-eminent perch? And will that create a kinder, gentler society — or will it undermine respect for other people and open the way to barbarism?
My co-panellists were Matthew Taylor, Tim Stanley and Mona Siddiqui. Our witnesses were Clare Bass, executive director of Humane Society International; Jim Barrington, animal welfare consultant for the Countryside Alliance; Steve Cooke, lecturer in political theory at the University of Leicester; and Nick Zangwill, philosopher and honorary research fellow at University College London and the University of Lincoln.
If you can access the BBC website, you can listen to the show here.
Recent posts
Premium subscribers can read my most recent exclusive post, on the convenient untruth being used to explain the recent terrible floods in Europe, if you click here.
And you can read my most recent post that’s available to everyone, on how the convolutions of the culture war have become a vile and frightening process, by clicking here.
One more thing…
This is how my website works.
It has two subscription levels: my free service and the premium service.
Anyone can sign up to the free service on this website. You can of course unsubscribe at any time by clicking “unsubscribe” at the foot of each email.
Everyone on the free list will receive the full text of pieces I write for outlets such as the Jewish News Syndicate and the Jewish Chronicle, as well as other posts and links to my broadcasting work.
But why not subscribe to my premium service? For that you’ll also receive pieces that I write specially for my premium subscribers. Those articles will not be published elsewhere. They’ll arrive in your inbox as soon as I have written them.
There is a monthly fee of $6.99 for the premium service, or $70 for an annual subscription. Although the fee is charged in US dollars, you can sign up with any credit card. Just click on the “subscribe now” button below to see the available options for subscribing either to the premium or the free service.
A note on subscriptions
If you purchase a subscription to my site, you will be authorising a payment to my company Dirah Associates. In the past, that is the name that may have appeared on your credit card statement. In future, though, the charge should appear instead as Melanie Phillips.
And thank you for following my work.